On-Premises vs. Cloud Computing: A Comprehensive Analysis of Benefits, Drawbacks, and Cost Considerations

9 min readJul 20, 2023

Delve into the on-premises vs. cloud computing debate, exploring the advantages and drawbacks of each approach. Figure out what fits your business needs best.

With enterprises increasingly seeking disruption through emerging technologies, adopting cloud solutions has become a critical strategic imperative. According to Gartner, all cloud market segments are poised for growth in 2023, setting the stage for further advancements. Gartner also predicts that by 2026, 75% of organizations will embrace a digital transformation model centered around the cloud as the underlying platform.

Amidst this cloud revolution, business owners often grapple with important decisions regarding their server infrastructure. The on-premise versus cloud computing debate stands as a significant point of contention. But don’t rush it — understanding the nuances between different types of computing is essential to make decisions that align with business goals and leverage the full potential of technology.

Related materials:

What Is On-Premise?

On-premise refers to deploying IT infrastructure and software within an organization’s physical premises, such as their own on-premises data centers or offices. The organization owns and manages the hardware, software licenses, and data configuration on-site in this setup. IT staff can control the servers, data storage, and management.

One of the advantages of on-premise computing is the level of control it provides. Since the data and infrastructure are physically accessible, teams have direct access to critical information, and there is no reliance on third-party providers for remote access.

In industries with stringent regulations and security requirements, such as the financial sector, on-premise solutions have been historically favored due to the perceived higher level of data security. However, on-premise solutions have some downsides. They require investment in server hardware, software licenses, integration capabilities, and an in-house IT team to support and handle potential issues. Additionally, organizations bear the responsibility of maintenance and repairs when problems occur.

It’s also worth noting that as cloud services evolve and address security concerns, the significance of on-premise solutions is diminishing in some industries.

What Is a Cloud Computing?

Cloud computing and on-premises software diverge significantly in one crucial aspect: hosting. While on-premises software requires a company to manage everything internally within their own infrastructure, cloud computing entrusts this responsibility to a third-party provider. This fundamental difference grants businesses the flexibility to pay for services on a consumption basis, allowing them to effortlessly scale resources up or down based on usage, user demands, and company growth.

The essence of cloud-based servers lies in their virtual technology, enabling applications to be hosted offsite. By doing so, companies are relieved of capital expenses, benefit from regular data backups, and only pay for the resources they actively utilize. Particularly appealing for organizations with ambitious global expansion plans, the cloud seamlessly connects businesses with customers, partners, and other stakeholders worldwide, requiring minimal effort and resources.

Moreover, the cloud boasts an edge in nearly instant provisioning, thanks to pre-configured environments. Integrating new software becomes a breeze as it becomes readily available upon subscription. Eliminating the time previously spent on installation and configuration, users gain immediate access to the application, fostering greater efficiency and productivity from the outset. With on-demand resource access, organizations can scale up or down as needed without the upfront costs of purchasing and maintaining hardware and software. The pay-as-you-go model means businesses pay only for the resources and services they use. Examples of cloud-based services include Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, Alibaba Cloud, IBM Cloud, and Salesforce.

On-Premise Vs. Cloud: Key Differences

While some core differences between on-premises and cloud software may be evident, let’s classify them into distinct categories. In this case, let’s pin them down in five key categories:

Deployment

On-premise software is deployed within the company’s own infrastructure, and the company is responsible for maintaining the solution and related processes. In contrast, cloud computing involves hosting the software on the service provider’s server, with the provider taking care of maintenance and accessibility for the enterprise.

Control

With on-premise deployment, companies have complete control over their systems and can maintain 100% privacy. In the cloud, although data and encryption keys may be shared with the third-party provider, there is still shared ownership, and the company’s accessibility to the system may be impacted during downtime.

Security

Security is a crucial concern for organizations when it comes to protecting financial, customer, and employee data. In an on-premise environment, security measures need to be implemented in-house to fully maintain data security. In the cloud model, ERP vendors usually have multiple disaster recovery and redundancy protocols in place to enhance data security.

Reliable network connectivity is vital for both on-premise and cloud environments, especially in remote areas.

Compliance

Companies need to adhere to regulatory controls and ensure compliance with government and industry regulations. In the case of on-premise, maintaining data in-house can help meet these mandates more easily. When choosing a cloud computing model, companies must ensure that the service provider meets the regulatory requirements of their specific industry.

Cost

Implementing an on-premise system involves significant upfront costs, including infrastructure purchases, additional processes, and ongoing operating and maintenance costs.

In contrast, cloud computing is generally more cost-effective, particularly for companies that optimize the use of resources. Additionally, cloud services often have lower setup and runtime costs, and companies typically pay a subscription fee that covers updates and maintenance provided by the cloud host.

Public Cloud vs. Private Cloud vs. Hybrid Cloud: Advantages and Disadvantages

When it comes to cloud computing, organizations have three main deployment options to choose from:

Public Cloud

One of the key characteristics of public cloud services is its multi-tenancy model. Multiple users and organizations share the same underlying infrastructure, but their data and applications remain logically isolated and secure. This shared infrastructure allows for economies of scale. The accessibility of public clouds over the internet allows users to access their applications and data from anywhere, using a variety of devices.

Advantages:

– Typically more cost-effective than any other deployment option
– No need to handle maintenance, updates, and infrastructure management
– Designed to provide high availability and ensure business continuity.
– Unparalleled scalability and elasticity
– Extensive global footprint with data centers located in multiple regions

Disadvantages:

– Can be susceptible to data breaches and cyber attacks
– Limited control over the infrastructure and resources, making customization difficult
– May experience downtime, temporarily affecting access to applications and data
– Unexpected costs, if usage exceeds anticipated levels or the pricing model, changes over time

Private Cloud

The primary characteristic of a private cloud is the dedicated and isolated nature of its resources. The hardware, software, and networking components are solely dedicated to serving the needs of a single organization.

Private clouds are commonly adopted by government agencies, financial institutions, and other mid-sized to large organizations with business-critical operations.

Advantages

– Offers a higher level of security as the organization has full control over the cloud service
– Makes it possible to customize the infrastructure and services to meet specific requirements
– Provides increased privacy (as long as there are robust controls over who accesses data and resources)

Disadvantages

– Can be expensive (acquiring and maintaining dedicated hardware, software, and networking infrastructure)
– Time-consuming and resource-intensive
– Requires technical expertise and specialized skills
– Still may be vulnerable to security risks
– May not be as scalable as public cloud services

Hybrid Cloud

Hybrid cloud solutions combine the use of both private cloud infrastructure and public cloud services. In some cases, the hybrid cloud provides orchestration, management, and application portability across the cloud, as well as on-premise. This creates a unified and flexible distributed computing environment in which organizations can run and scale their traditional or cloud-native workloads using the most suitable computing model.

Advantages

– Effective combination of all deployment options
– Flexibility of storing sensitive data in a private cloud and taking advantage of the scalability of a public cloud
– Ability to move workloads between private and public clouds as needed
– Provides enhanced business continuity and disaster recovery capabilities
– Reduces dependency on a single cloud vendor

Disadvantages

– Requires integration between different cloud environments, which can be complex
– Can be more expensive due to additional hardware, software, and infrastructure needs
– A lack of standardization between different environments
– Communication between different cloud storage environments can result in network latency and performance issues
– Compatibility can be challenging

On-Premise to Cloud Migration

The Gartner framework, commonly known as “the six Rs of migration,” provides various options for cloud migration:

Rehosting (lift-and-shift): transferring applications to the cloud without making any changes to their code or architecture.
Replatforming: making minor optimizations to applications to leverage cloud capabilities without altering their fundamental architecture.
Refactoring: a complete rewrite of applications to utilize cloud-native features like auto-scaling and serverless computing.
Repurchasing: replacing existing applications with cloud-native Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) platforms, such as transitioning from a custom CRM to Salesforce.
Retiring: disabling or decommissioning certain applications are not suitable for cloud migration.

Transitioning cloud migration steps, organizations can use the six Rs as a starting point to define their strategy. The following steps provide a high-level overview of the application migration process:

1. Prepare for the Migration

Establish objectives and KPIs to ensure a viable and economically sound migration. You also need to evaluate the reasons for migration and consider factors like cost savings and scalability and use cloud providers’ pricing calculators to estimate expenses.

2. Re-Engineer Your Application’s Architecture

Depending on your migration approach, you may need to re-architect your application. This could involve virtualizing your application, using containerization technologies, or modularizing your code to migrate portions to the cloud while keeping others on-premises.

3. Choose the Right Cloud Migration Tools

Research and select tools that align with your specific requirements.

4. Migration and Execution

Create a business case for each application you plan to transfer to the cloud, with consideration of projected operational benefits, cost savings, and architectural enhancements. Validate each migrated element to ensure proper functioning and synchronize changes made to the source data during the transfer.

5. Evaluation and Optimization

Once your application is in production, evaluate its performance and ensure users have access to the required functionality and data. Measure KPIs and review user incident tickets to understand the impact of the migration. It also helps to monitor financials to avoid overbilling and use expense management solutions.

Remember that migrating to the cloud is not a magic bullet and focus on leveraging technology to drive innovation.

Which Is the Right Solution for Your Business?

Whether you choose on-premises, public cloud, or a hybrid platform, it’s essential to conduct a thorough investigation to ensure the best outcomes for your organization.

Transitioning from legacy software to cloud adoption is often a logical step to unlock maximum benefits while minimizing effort and costs. However, executive leaders need to consider their organization’s culture and business priorities when justifying a cloud migration. Finding the right balance between private and public cloud resources is also essential.

If you require additional assistance or feel uncertain about your data migration project, consider seeking guidance from experienced providers. The team will provide an in-depth analysis of your enterprise, helping you navigate the complexities of cloud adoption and migration. Get a free consultation by reaching us out.

FAQ

Why Cloud Computing vs. On-premise?

Cloud is better for businesses with dynamic resource needs, remote work, and limited upfront investment. Unless your organization has an established IT infrastructure, it rarely makes sense to invest in building and maintaining on-premise infrastructure.

What Is AWS On-premises vs. Cloud Computing?

AWS Cloud is a cloud-based service that offers scalability, flexibility, and pay-as-you-go pricing. Its on-premises version is called AWS Outposts, and it allows organizations to run AWS services and APIs locally while integrating with the broader AWS ecosystem. Essentially, both rely on the cloud computing environment, Outposts simply helps you run AWS services locally in your organization.

Is On-premise Safer than Cloud?

Both on-premise and cloud environments can be secured effectively with appropriate measures and best practices. That said, if your enterprise lacks the necessary resources and staff to invest in on-premise security tools and keep up with the changing requirements, utilizing cloud services may provide a more practical and secure option.

Is Cloud Faster than On-premise?

For certain workloads that require low latency or have specific performance requirements, an on-premise solution may offer faster processing times. But when it comes to deployment and introducing new changes, the cloud enables unparalleled advantages.